I have been really concerned lately about some issues that keep cropping up in SL and in particular in the surf community. V has covered the politics, so I thought I would share a little about the issues that bother me other than politics.
I love the designers, creators and scripters in SL, who made the world what it is today, and who give us such enjoyment, such fulfillment in SL. Each of these individuals took the time to plan something, to draft it, to design it, to test it, and finally to release it to us all. Many or most sell those creations of theirs as is their right.
I think it is important to realize that SL is NOT a game in the slightest. It is a commercial platform that offers entertainment to some and creative expression for others, but it costs money, a LOT of money. I have already shared with you all just what the Resort has cost us since creation (over US$25,000) and many many other residents who own land have paid many more US$ to bring us the beauty and diversity we see in SL today.
Now for many designers the product becomes their livelihood even in RL, that supports them on a full time basis so that they can focus on bringing us even more wonderful products and scripts. For them protecting their interests is a serious concern and hence we have many products sold with no permissions other that Transfer OR Copy. Few sell their products with Modify rights these days, and when you do buy such a product treat that permission as a privilege afforded to you by the creator of the product. Do not abuse it!
This is where I am very concerned at the moment about our surf products. I am in agreement that the wonderful products created by Heather and Seb have been directly responsible for the most amazing virtual surf environment ever in SL. Without those products we would not be here enjoying surfing as we have. I know that the closeness of the product range has frustrated some too, and this is understandable as the products have not reduced much in price over time and the scripts have not been written for others to manipulate (all very much Heather and Seb’s right by the way). I wholly agree that this closeness has encouraged others who are able to rethink how scripts in waves and surfboards/windsurfers/kites may work and to try their own hand in developing a new range of products. After all competition will only benefit the surfing community.
What I am concerned about, and very much against, is the similarity of some products to the current HG line of products and it especially worries me when some of the creators of ‘new’ wave and board products had in their possession HG products with MOD rights. I am not pointing fingers at anyone, but I want to make this very clear. I am AGAINST any product illegally based on someone else’s hard work and innovation! If designers take the time to develop their own products from the ground up, I am 100% behind them. However, if that designer had scripted objects from a HG product line with MOD rights, and their own products are not very dissimilar to HG’s line of products, I for one will be HIGHLY suspicious of the authenticity of the new product range!
I am not saying all this in support of a monopoly. I too have my doubts about the costs of current wave and board products, and the limited access to more innovation in them because of their closeness. I am not a mouthpiece for HG either, dang, I only wish I had more contact with her on a daily basis, but I barely speak to her once a term. I am just stating here that as far as Dumisani Ah is concerned, though wholly supporting new innovations and creations based on fresh approaches and built from the ground up, I am drawing the line for me personally on supporting new product lines that seem cloned from the current line of surf products in SL. If I have a doubt about a product’s origin or authenticity, I will remove that product from the Resort and will ban anyone associated with it!
However, if you are a designer wishing to make your own line of products and you have taken the time, like HG and Seb did all that many months ago, to study RL waves and board action, and then taken the time to try and replicate those in your own original way in your own original product line you will have my wholehearted congratulations and support!